Freedom of the press is no joke in the Philippines
Author: Danilo Araña Arao, University of the Philippines Diliman
By presenting the Nobel Peace Prize to journalists Maria Ressa and Dmitry Muratov on October 8, 2021, the Norwegian Nobel Committee shed light on the state of press freedom in the Philippines and Russia – and rightly so.
The Philippines are ranked 130th and Russia 152nd in the Reporters Without Borders 2021 Global Press Freedom Index. The Philippines and Russia also ranked 7th and 10th respectively in the Committee to Protect Journalists’ 2021 Global Impunity Index.
While the media situation in the two countries deserves close examination, the Philippines is a particularly interesting case. The Philippine press is widely regarded as one of the freest in Asia, but it remains one of the most dangerous places in the world to practice journalism. Press freedom and human rights advocates continue to speak out against the dominant culture of impunity that the government says ended under the administration of Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte.
Cases filed against a leading online media organization To recall and its CEO Maria Ressa made world headlines. Duterte criticized To recall for peddling “fake news” and his license was revoked in 2018 – ironic given Ressa’s investigative work exposing disinformation on social media. In June 2020, Ressa and former To recall reporter Reynaldo Santos, Jr. were convicted of cyber defamation.
Like the late dictator Ferdinand Marcos who ordered the shutdown of the ABS-CBN broadcast network in 1972, Duterte said in 2019 that ABS-CBN would be “out of service” when its franchise expired in 2020. During one vote in the House of Representatives in July 2020, the broadcast network was closed.
Under the Duterte administration, news organizations and journalists were punished or accused of being Communist sympathizers, and at least two journalists were arrested and detained. Cyber attacks have also been launched against news organizations’ websites in an attempt to prevent them from doing their jobs. While distributed denial of service attacks – which overwhelm servers with too many data requests to shut them down – have been occurring since 2018, the most recent attack on two news outlets was carried out by the Philippine military.
At least 190 journalists have been killed since 1986, including 21 during the Duterte administration. The prevailing climate of media repression sends a frightening message to journalists and media professionals across the country that they must follow the administrative line.
National and local elections in the Philippines will be held in May 2022. It is unclear to what extent the state of press freedom will be raised as an electoral issue.
Candidates are expected to articulate the usual rhetoric about preserving democracy, including the importance of a vibrant press. Not surprisingly, Duterte and his supporters have denied the media crackdown. They claimed that the closure of ABS-CBN and To recallThe legal problems of s are isolated cases which do not affect the other news media in the country.
While some government officials continue to engage in red marking journalists and news media, government agencies contend that their officials are simply expressing their personal views and not official policy. The Philippine National Police denies the existence of a culture of impunity that violates the rights of journalists and other sectors of society.
Journalists, media professionals and other affected groups must lobby for press freedom to be an electoral issue. Candidates in the 2022 polls should make it clear where they stand, beyond the usual rhetoric of defending democracy and fundamental freedoms.
For a president known to joke on serious matters, Duterte now finds it embarrassing to congratulate Ressa. Its spokesperson belatedly admitted Ressa was the first Filipino Nobel Peace Prize winner while trying to play down the idea that the prize was a “slap in the face” of the government. It is not credible for Duterte to sincerely congratulate Ressa, whose journalistic feat was born out of the fight against the repression he perpetuates.
In the Philippines, threats to press freedom are real. It should not be reduced to a simple joke, especially for those who claim to defend it while engaging in repression.
Danilo Araña Arao is Associate Professor in the Department of Journalism, University of the Philippines Diliman, Special Lecturer in the Department of Journalism, Polytechnic University of the Philippines Santa Mesa, Associate Editor at Bulatlat Multimedia and editor at Asia Media.